Friday, August 23, 2013
NDC lauds NPP for going to court, calls for all-inclusive government
Statement: Rethinking Ghana's winner-takes-all system - IEA
Tuesday, August 20, 2013
US issues alert on court verdict
The American Embassy in Ghana is not out of place in cautioning its citizens to be wary of the political situation in Ghana, the deputy minister of the Interior, Mr James Agalga, has said.
"I don't think the American Embassy, in sending a word of caution to its citizens, is totally out of place because, as a country, we ourselves have sent warnings and cautions to the people many times not to overreact to the verdict.
"For instance, the Ghana Catholic Bishops Conference and some civil society organisations have called on Ghanaians not to over-celebrate or overreact after the declaration, so the Americans sending a word of caution to their citizens to be careful of what is likely to happen following the Supreme Court verdict on August 29, is not wrong," he said.
The deputy minister, who was reacting to a statement issued by the American Embassy ahead of the Supreme Court verdict, said, "As a ministry and a government, we have, time without number, assured Ghanaians that the security agencies are alert and taking measures so that after the declaration lives will be protected. Ghanaians should go about j their normal activities without fear or favour."
He said although it was within the right of the US Embassy to advise its citizens, there was no cause for alarm, as the security agencies were on top of issues.
Mr Agalga admitted that the fact that every Ghanaian was concerned and preaching peace was a clear indication that one could not rule our isolated cases of violence.
The US Embassy had, in a statement, warned about a potential increase in political tension and the possibility of isolated violence associated with the Supreme Court verdict on the 2012 presidential election pending before the court since December 28, 2013.
"US citizens in Ghana are reminded to maintain a high level of vigilance and to take appropriate steps to increase their security/safety awareness during this politically sensitive period. US citizens in Ghana should avoid the offices of political parties, Ghana's Supreme Court, the buildings of other institutions associated with the elections and all political rallies," it said.
"We recommend that US citizens in Ghana monitor the local news and avoid all demonstrations, as even those intended robe peaceful may suddenly turn violent" it said.
The statement from the US Embassy had inflamed passions, with critics of the embassy saying the statement had the potential to further heighten tension.
But the deputy minister said the statement was not something that should cause fear and panic.
He urged Ghanaians "to go about their normal activities without fear or favour, as nothing will happen. The security agencies are ready to deal with the situation".
Allaying the fears of Ghanaians concerning the statement, the Information Officer of the American Embassy, Ms. Jean Clarke, said the warning was not based on signals picked by the embassy pointing to violence but rather a routine message to its citizens.
"It is a routine process for us. If you remember, in December, we issued a similar statement but nothing happened. Even during the Kenyan elections this year, a similar caution was given to our citizens she said.
She said there were many US citizens in Ghana in one activity or another. Therefore, it was obligatory for the embassy to inform them about the security situation to enable them to adopt an appropriate security posture.
"We don't want Ghanaians to be alarmed. This is just routine," she added.
Monday, August 19, 2013
'Touchline' to Supreme Court; Police set 100-metre radius
Thursday, August 15, 2013
Ghana Election Petition Ruling, August 29
The clarification, which was used to wind up seven months of hearing of the petition, was in respect of re-categorisation of some exhibits submitted to the court, explanation of 'preferred date set', definition of over voting, statutory consequences of electoral irregularities, and dire consequences without going through the Biometric Verification Device (BVD).
Others were on the principle of annulling election results, retroactive application of the law, and invalidation of the results and statutory consequences of electoral irregularity.
Philip Addison, lead counsel for the petitioners, set the ball rolling when Justice William Atuguba, the presiding Judge of the nine-member panel, wanted him to clarify how the petitioners re-categorised some of their exhibits submitted to the court.
He explained that the petitioners began with 11,842 polling stations set out in the further and better particulars, but deleted 704, reducing the number to 10,119 polling stations.
Mr. Addison said the criteria for including the pink sheets had been captured in the further and better particulars in the KPMG report and was used only once in their analysis.
Giving a breakdown of the polling stations used, he indicated that 7,999 unique pink sheets from the court registrar's set, 960 unique polling stations recovered from what the KPMG excluded, 804 pink sheets from the presiding judges' set, 60 remarks recovered from the presiding Judges set that were unclear to KPMG and 566 pink sheets used by the petitioners.
On over-voting, Mr. Addison said a polling station may move from over-voting category to no signature of the presiding officers category and that 83 pink sheets were deleted in the over-voting category.
When Justice Jones Dotse, a member of the panel, asked Mr. Addison what he meant by 'preferred data set', he cited pages in the petitioners' addresses which consisted of a cited pages of duplicate polling station codes.
He said that respondents explained that there were duplicate polling station codes because some were used for special voting while others were used to split large polling stations into A and B.
Justice Atuguba asked James Quarshie- Idun, counsel for the Electoral Commission (EC), about the statutory consequences of electoral irregularities that he alone identified in his address.
He read out portions of his address that related to an authority that a High Court hearing an election petition could uphold an election conducted in accordance to High Court rules but Justice Atuguba said his explanation was not acceptable and needed to be clarified.
But Mr. Quarshie-Idun insisted that a High Court was empowered to dismiss claims of irregularity if certain conditions were not met.
In an intervention, Justice Rose Owusu, a member of the panel said Constitutional Instrument (CI) 75 was the regulation made for presidential election and suggested that that should be the focus of his case.
Justice Atuguba disagreed with Mr. Quarshie-Idun when he said he did not think a C.I. could make modifications to an Act but said if the Act permitted it, then it was possible.
When it was the turn of Tony Lithur, counsel for President John Mahama, Justice Atuguba wanted to find out why he (Lithur) wrote in his address that failure to go through BVD did not go with any dire consequences.
He explained that the BVD was a process of capturing biometric data which involved a person's picture and the purpose was also to identify if a person was eligible and that once the process of registration was done, then his right to vote is activated.
Mr. Lithur added that even if a person's finger print could not be identified and his face could be identified then there is the discretionary power to allow him/her to vote and that finger print verification was not the only form of verification.
Mr. Lithur described as false the petitioners' assertion that since people's finger prints were not verified, then it meant people voted without the BVD.
Asked to explain retroactive application of the law and invalidation of the results which was sub-mitted in his address, Tsatsu Tsikata, counsel for the NDC, contended that Article 49 of the constitution should not in any stretch of imagination lead to the annulment of votes.
He said it was the duty for party agents and presiding officers to sign the pink sheets and if in the discharge of public duty they both fail to per-form their duties it did not mean votes must be annulled.
Mr. Tsikata submitted that there must be a frown on penalizing people retroactively, since presiding officers could not be penalized without a specific law mandating them to sign pink sheets and that the voter who had no role to play in the presiding officers' failure to uphold the law.
During interventions by some members of the bench about Mr. Tsikata's assertion, James Quarshie-Idun rose to draw the court's attention to regulations in C.I. 72 which indicated that the BVD must capture 10 finger prints and photo-graph.
When Mr. Quarshie-Idun drew the court's attention that a cancelled pink sheet found its way into the petitioners address, Justice Dotse questioned why he did not use his turn during the oral address to point out the anormaly, he could not answer but blamed it on the duties of a presiding officer at a polling station. Probing further if there was any entry for the presiding officer to sign before declaration, Mr Quarshie-Idun said they signed only after declaration of the results.
Mr. Tsikata disagreed with Justice Atuguba when he (Atuguba) referred him to an assertion by Mr. Addison that there were no mix up in the petitioner's exhibits and insisted that the confusion had not been addressed. He said in 2120 polling stations. 1029 had the same exhibit numbers but different polling stations, so it was difficult to know which polling station was been referred to and that the petitioners should have clarified the situation during the cross examination stage of hearing.
Judgment has been slated for August 29, 2013. The historic case led to a legal brainstorm for the past seven months. The 11-member legal team of the petitioners is being led by Philip Addison. Others are Ms.Gloria Akuffo, a former deputy Attorney General and Minister for Justice, Stephen Dapaah Addo, Egbert Fabille Jnr, Professor Ken Agyeman Attafah, Nana Asante Bediatuo, Alex Quaynor, Frank Davies, Kweku Asrifi and Godfred Yeboah Dame.
The legal team of President John Mahama, the first respondent is being represented by Tony Lithur and Dr. Basit Aziz Bamda. The EC, the second respondent is made up of James Quarshie-Idun, with assistance from Anthony Dabi, Stanley Amarteifio, Freda Bruce-Appiah and Stepanie Amarteifio.
The third respondent, the NDC, is being represented by Tsatsu Tsikata and Samuel Cudjoe. The petitioners, the presidential candidate for the New Patriotic Party (NPP) for the December 2012 elections, Nana Addo Dankwa Akuffo-Addo, his running mate, Dr. Mahamudu Bawumia and the chairman of the NPP Mr Obetsebi-Lamptey are challenging the results of the 2012 presidential election which the Electora Commision (EC) declared President John Mahama the winner.
They are contending that 'gross and widespread irregularities' took place in 11,916 polling stations. The petitioners are, therefore, calling for annulment of 4,670,504 votes cast in the 11.916 polling stations. But the respondents, President Mahama, the Electoral Commission and the National Democratic Congress(NDC) first, second and third respectively, have denied any wrong doing and are in view that the polls were free, fair and transparent and for that reason, the results were credible and accurate.
The nine-member panel of judges hearing the petition is presided over by Justice William Atuguba. Other members are Justice Julius Ansah, Mrs, Justice Sophia Adinyira, Ms. Justice Rose Owusu, Justice Jones Dotse, Justice Anim Yeboah, Justice Paul Baffoe-Bonnie, Justice N.S Gbadegbe and Mrs. Justice Akoto-Bamfo.
Source: Ghanaian Times
Friday, January 25, 2013
Of the Supreme Court, disputed election results and the dilemma of the Ghanaian public
Peter N. Amponsah, Catholic University College of Ghana, Fiapre
Regarding the election dispute currently before Ghana's Supreme Court, three views exist in the public sphere. They are: that the opposition NPP has no evidence and is just whining as a sour loser; that the sceptics of the Ghana judiciary believe that even if the NPP has adequate evidence of cheating it would be ignored by the Court; and that the optimists trust that if the NPP has the evidence the Court will give a landmark judgment, which will turn the situation around and transform the country's electoral exercise permanently.
The enthusiasts of the first view, which is typified mostly by the NDC and the EC, argue that the NPP's petition has no merit. They contend that there was no electoral fraud. For the NDC the election outcome reflects a poor showing of the NPP campaign whose leadership goes to court as a ploy to appease the anger of the NPP party's supporters. According to the defenders of this view, it would have been politically more expedient for the NPP to concede defeat and reorganise itself for a better performance in 2016.
If the allegation of political subterfuge were true, the NPP's action would amount to an offensive game playing with both the highest court of the land and the emotions of millions of NPP supporters, as well as waste of the nation's time and resources. Moreover, after regional and international observers had commented on the elections as reasonably free and fair, it would be unfortunate if the NPP took their petition to the Court without any concrete evidence to warrant a hearing. So, one may find it doubtful that a right-thinking, well-meaning person would violate political astuteness for such a political misstep.
The next two views represent an unrelieved dilemma of other Ghanaians: the conflict between scepticism and optimism. On the one hand, some citizens allege that the Court will not have the courage to overturn the Electoral Commission's declaration even if the evidence of electoral fraud corroborates the NPP's claim. This group of people opines that we are in Africa, and overturning such a verdict can never happen. So for such forecasters it is a fruitless step going to the Court to resolve such a critical political impasse. Such apathetic view reminisces from the continent's post-colonial past where unilateralism of some ruling governments succeeded in cowing other branches of governance.
However, in proffering this sceptic view, one succumbs to pessimism that does not propel development of a strong democratic culture. Its apathetic projection reminds one of the Greek mythological Sisyphus, the cunning king of Corinth who was punished in Hell and had to repeatedly roll a huge stone up a hill; but his efforts remained fruitless because the stone rolled down again as soon as he brought it to the summit. Along similar lines, the doubters spin a negative perception of the judiciary failing to assert itself as a branch of government with equal power as the executive. This group plies its projection with the German philosopher Ludwig Feuerbach, who asserts that we are inescapably hooked to our individual isolation booth. Thus, holders of the sceptic view resign themselves to expect no change; it is simply the same old game of power versus truism.
On the other hand, Ghana's democracy should not play that mythical Sisyphus. Thus, a section of the citizenry trusts that the Court in Ghana can make the difference to chart a truly maturing democracy in which the law is not a respecter of persons but truthfulness and justice, and it is exercised without fear or favour. For example, it took the Justices of the United States Supreme Court to brave such decisions as the Brown v. Board of Education I (1954) 347 US 483 and Brown v. Board of Education II (1955) 349 US 294 to end racial segregation and promote civil liberties on constitutional grounds.
Again, in 2004, the Ukranian Supreme Court could overturn a presidential election in which Viktor F. Yanukovich was declared winner while Viktor A. Yushchenko, the opposition leader, had been denied his rightful victory. Hence, the optimists trust that even though Ghana's Justices do not control the national purse cannot create edifices and infrastructure for the country, they are capable of building enduring monuments in terms of landmark decisions that can strengthen Ghana's democracy for the benefit of both the present generation and posterity.
The dilemma of the two views is not merely an alternation of emotions, but implications resulting from chicanery, political rhetoric and altercations. The neutrality, objectivity and firmness on the part of the Justices are crucial in their scrutiny of the case. If the allegation of electoral fraud lacks evidence and is unsupported it would be a regrettable suit; but the able Court will give a solid opinion that will both enrich constitutional law and educate the citizenry.
An outcome that would suggest that the Justices overlooked evidence in order to preserve the status quo – no need to disturb the state of affairs now that a new president is sworn in – may confirm the apathetic viewpoint. In that case, the judiciary may lose its integrity and credibility. Many citizens will lose confidence in the judiciary to settle a matter of this kind next time. It will indicate a weakness of a Court that cannot guarantee justice and, in an extreme scenario, people may take the law into their own hands.
To let pass successful electoral fraud, if supported, would encourage a repeat either by the same party or its counterparts in the future. So, instead of ending electoral cheating in order to solidify our democracy, it will be excused and perpetuated. Consequently, electoral cheating will reduce voters' confidence and lead to democratic decline. The case is a serious one for lovers of democracy because a successful electoral fraud has the likened effect of a coup d'état of the ballot in the strict sense. In a tempered sense, it typifies a corruption of democracy; a breakdown of democracy that leads to fostering of dictatorship.
In contrast, an outcome that would suggest that the Justices upheld the substantiation of the case (that is, if the evidence available supports that claim) will build confidence in the judicial system and chart a new course in voting and Ghana's democracy. The optimists presume the trustworthiness of the Court; it will neither allow the Executive to control it nor interfere in its work nor cajole its decision. The Court knows very well that it has to operate by the principle of the checks and balances under-girding the separation of powers that resides in the three arms of government. Just as the Court does not interfere in the work of the Executive and that of the Legislature, so the Court will not defeat itself by tolerating an external force's intrusion into its jurisdiction. This way, the strong and independent Court leads the presently desired campaign to build strong institutions. It is achievable by braving each case as an opportunity for advancement and by standing on the side of the truth in all cases no matter whose ox is gored.
All well-meaning Ghanaians expect the Justices to go into examining the merits of the case as neutral "referees" without bias or prejudice and to let truthfulness and justice flow from the pinnacle of constitutional heights. Ghana will ever be grateful to them for this service of creditable legal performance, unlike Roger Brooke Taney (1777-1864) who could have been considered among the United States' great jurists but brought infamy upon himself because of his judgment in Scott v. Sandford (1857) 60 US 393. Chief Justice Taney, who succeeded the famous Chief Justice John Marshall in 1836, gave an inflammatory opinion of the Court in the Dred Scott case that viewed the alleged inferiority of blacks with constitutional backing and held that blacks could not be citizens of the United States.
All in all, Ghana's democracy must progress rather than roll back to ground zero if the Court were to sustain our democratic gains. The electoral dispute currently before the Supreme Court is an opportunity for the Court to demonstrate Ghana's democratic maturity and to strengthen the country's institutions. The Court's objectivity in examining the evidence and determining the truthfulness and reasonableness of the alleged electoral fraud will provide a landmark judgment to benefit Ghana's jurisprudence, sustain democracy and foment national pride.
Sunday, January 6, 2013
Ghana : Parliament to reconvene mid-night Sunday
About 177 members of the Fifth Parliament would move into the Sixth Parliament as they won their re-election bids in the December 7 Parliamentary election. They will be joined by 97 new entrants in the Sixth Parliament.
The NDC will dominate the Sixth Parliament with 148 seats, with the NPP occupying 122 seats and four Independent members in the House.
A by-election is expected to be conducted in the next 60 days to elect a new member for the Buem Constituency due to the passing of the MP-elect Henry Kamel, who was also Volta regional Minister.
After the dissolution of the Fifth Parliament on the stroke of midnight of Sunday, the 274 Members-elect would on January 7, elect the First and Second Deputy Speakers, as well as the Speaker of Parliament.
The substantive Speaker will on the morning of the January 7, swear in the new MPs as dictated by the Constitution, into the Sixth Parliament.
There was initial confusion over the timeline for the dissolution of the Fifth Parliament and the inauguration of the Sixth Parliament, owing to an inconsistency in a provision in the Presidential (Transition) Act, 2012 (Act 845).
Section 11 (1) of the Act provides that the Clerk of Parliament summons a meeting of the elected members of parliament two days before the dissolution of Parliament to elect the Speaker, Deputy Speakers and take the oaths of office as members.
Section 11(3) of the Act further provides: "The Speaker elected under sub-section (1) and the Members of Parliament who take their oaths of office under that sub-section, assume office subject to the operations of Article 113 of the Constitution, and accordingly take office on the 7th of January following the general election."
Both sections of Act 845 are inconsistent with provisions of the 1992 Constitution. Article 113 (2) states that Parliament shall continue for four years from the date of its first sitting and shall then stand dissolved, indicative that the current Parliament stands dissolved on January 6, 2013, considering that its first sitting was on January 7, 2009.
Article 95 (1) of the Constitution further stipulates: "There shall be a Speaker of Parliament who shall be elected by the Members of Parliament from among persons who are Members of Parliament or who are qualified to be elected as Members of Parliament."
The Fifth Parliament which is due to be dissolved midnight on Sunday, has 230 members, comprising 116 seats for the National Democratic Congress (NDC), 106 seats for the New Patriotic Party (NPP), two seats for the People's National Convention (PNC), one seat for the Convention People's Party (CPP) and three independent seats.
Among the members are 19 women parliamentarians, 13 from the NPP, five from the NDC and one from the CPP.
Six of the members passed on during the Fifth Parliament, the recent one being the MP for Buem, Henry Ford Kamel, who died on Christmas Day, December 25, 2012.